Flags are more than fabric flapping in the wind. They’re symbols of identity, rallying cries, and political statements all rolled into one. So when someone suggests changing one—whether it’s a local town banner or a national ensign—you can bet there’ll be opinions flying as fast as the flag itself. And you know what? Those redesign debates often reveal just how powerful these symbols really are.
Let’s unpack the complicated, emotional, and often controversial world of flag redesigns.
Why Change a Flag in the First Place?
You’d think a flag, once stitched into a nation's history, would be untouchable. But history’s got a funny way of challenging that idea.
Sometimes the reason for a redesign is practical—like clarity at a distance or making a design more inclusive. Other times, it’s deeply political. A flag might be tied to colonial history, a painful past, or a government long gone. When societies evolve, so does the symbolism they choose to display.
Here are a few big motivators:
Post-colonial identity shifts: Nations like South Africa redesigned their flags after apartheid to reflect unity over division.
Design confusion: The flags of Australia and New Zealand, for instance, are so similar that even citizens mix them up.
Calls for inclusivity: Some cities and states have updated flags to better represent Indigenous communities or marginalized groups.
Visual improvements: Vexillologists (flag experts) often push for simpler, bolder designs that align with good design principles—think fewer colors, meaningful symbols, and no hard-to-see seals.
Want to learn more about what makes a flag work? Check out The Design Principles of Flags.
A Quick History of (Sometimes Heated) Flag Redesigns
Let’s walk through a few famous—or infamous—cases where flag redesign became a national flashpoint.
South Africa: A Flag for a New Era
After apartheid ended in the early '90s, South Africa needed a fresh start. The old flag symbolized white-minority rule. The new design, introduced in 1994, used six colors to symbolize unity in diversity. While initially described as temporary, it resonated so strongly that it became permanent.
It’s now widely celebrated as one of the world’s most successful political rebrandings—vexillologically and socially.
The Flag of South Africa
View Flag →New Zealand: Too Close for Comfort
In 2016, New Zealand held a referendum to potentially replace its flag. The issue? Too many people confused it with Australia’s. The proposed redesign—featuring a silver fern—sparked national debates. Was it too sporty? Too commercial? Too… unpatriotic?
After spending $26 million and months of debate, voters chose to keep the original. Democracy spoke. But it also showed just how reluctant people can be to let go of their visual history.
Mississippi: Letting Go of the Confederate Legacy
In 2020, Mississippi replaced its state flag—the last one in the U.S. to include the Confederate emblem. It had long been a source of pain and division. The redesign, featuring a magnolia and the phrase “In God We Trust,” was seen by many as a healing gesture.
Yet not everyone was on board. Critics claimed the change was rushed or politically motivated. But the message was clear: sometimes progress demands bold visual steps.
The Struggle Between Tradition and Change
Flag redesigns aren't just about aesthetics—they’re emotional battlegrounds. People cling to flags the way they cling to memories. Change a flag, and it can feel like rewriting history.
Here’s the rub: every flag carries baggage. The stars and stripes? Revolutionary pride for some, systemic failure for others. The Union Jack? A symbol of global heritage—or colonial dominance, depending on your vantage point.
This tug-of-war plays out in design briefs and public forums alike. On one side, traditionalists fear erasing identity. On the other, reformers see redesign as long overdue. It's not just politics. It's personal.
Can a Good Flag Design Heal Old Wounds?
Sometimes, yes.
Great flag design isn’t just about clean lines and bold colors. It’s about symbolism—about saying this is who we are now. When done right, a redesign can bridge divides, celebrate diversity, and unite a population around a shared vision.
Take Chicago’s city flag: simple, symbolic, and beloved. Or Canada’s Maple Leaf, adopted in 1965 to distance itself from colonial ties. These flags don’t just look good—they feel right. That’s a powerful thing.
When Redesigns Fail: Lessons from Vexillology Gone Wrong
Not all redesigns stick the landing. A few memorable flops:
Pocatello, Idaho: Dubbed “the worst city flag in America” in a 2004 TED Talk by Roman Mars. It featured a crowded, low-resolution image of a mountain. The good news? Public embarrassment prompted a fantastic community-led redesign in 2017.
Georgia (U.S. state): Between 2001 and 2003, Georgia cycled through multiple designs trying to distance itself from Confederate symbolism—resulting in confusion and controversy. It took several tries to get it (mostly) right.
These cases show how not to do a redesign: without community input, historical sensitivity, or a clear design mission.
What Makes a Redesign Actually Work?
Good question. Here’s what successful flag makeovers tend to have in common:
Public engagement: Involve citizens early and often. Flags are for people—not politicians.
Professional guidance: Bring in artists and vexillologists to guide aesthetics and symbolism.
Simplicity: The best flags can be drawn from memory by a child. That’s not a joke—it’s a design test.
Meaningful change: Don’t just rebrand for the sake of it. Make sure the redesign responds to real cultural, political, or identity shifts.
Redesigns on the Horizon?
Several flags are under review—or under fire—as of 2025. Will the UK ever update its Union Jack to include Wales? Could Hawaii or Puerto Rico reimagine their flags amid evolving debates about independence and identity?
Even the International Flag of Planet Earth, a speculative design by Oskar Pernefeldt, suggests we’re already thinking beyond national borders to planetary identity.
Flags: More Than Symbols
At the end of the day (okay, not literally), flags aren’t just decorations—they’re declarations. Every redesign tells a story about who we were, who we are, and who we want to be.
And while flag redesigns may spark tension, debate, or even backlash, they also show us that change is possible—one stitch, stripe, or star at a time.
Keep Exploring
If you enjoyed this piece, you might also like: